Brian Zinchuk: Trump won. Let’s build that pipeline, quick!
A remarkable alignment between Trump, the US House and Senate, Danielle Smith, Scott Moe and maybe Pierre Poilievre could make it happen.
It was May 26, 2016, when I had the chance to ask Donald Trump if he would approve the Keystone XL pipeline.
On that day in Bismarck, North Dakota, he had just secured enough delegates to become the presumptive Republican candidate for president.
I asked if he would approve the Keystone XL. He said he would, but he wanted a piece.
Donald Trump on May 26, 2016, when he was asked by Brian Zinchuk if he would approve the Keystone XL pipeline. Photo by Brian Zinchuk
It was the biggest moment in my journalism career. The saga of what happened since then is too long to recreate, other than it the only portions built were in Alberta, paid for by the Province of Alberta. This past year, after 18 years of heartbreak and misery, TC Energy announced it was dumping its experiment into oil pipelines like a despised soon-to-be-ex-wife.
TC Energy announced on July 27 it would spin off a new liquids pipelines company from its natural gas pipelines and power generation business. The new company, South Bow, took the 72 kilometre, 20 inch White Spruce Pipeline and 460 kilometre, 20 inch Grand Rapid Pipeline in northern Alberta. But those were chicken feed. The spin off was all about the half-continent spanning 30 and 36 inch Keystone System/Marketlink which runs 4,324 kilometres from Hardisty, Alberta, to the U.S. Gulf Coast.
Well, TC Energy might be rethinking their spinoff now. Oops.
Just months after the Trans Mountain Expansion (TMX) going online, the Canadian oil industry is already looking for its next export pipeline.
At the Lloydminster Heavy Oil Show, Alberta Premier Danielle Smith brought up something remarkable – the idea of dusting off pipeline projects that were dead and buried. One project she mentioned was Keystone XL.
She said on Sept. 11, “I would also love to see a restart of some kind of project on Keystone XL. Maybe that route was not the right one. Maybe if they just twinned the existing route? Maybe that would have been the pathway to go, because we managed to get Line 3 and Trans Mountain done on the basis of using an existing right of way.”
It’s an intriguing idea, especially since nearly all of the Canadian pipe is in the ground. As mentioned above, Alberta paid for the construction of the line from Hardisty to close to the Saskatchewan border at Empress, Alberta. That was supposed to be the starting point for KXL to go straight southwest through Saskatchewan, Montana, South Dakota to Steele City, Nebraska.
But it was also supposed to be the starting point for the doomed Energy East pipeline. That line was supposed to make use of an underused 42 inch line in the TransCanada mainline, converting it to natural gas, and extending it past Kingston, Ontario to Saint John, New Brunswick.
While I still think we should revive that project, if we can’t, then we should use that pipe to revive the Keystone idea.
Call it Keystone II. Or better yet, call it something totally different. Trump 1. I don’t care. Anything but Keystone. And he’d approve Trump 1 in a New York minute
So you start at Hardisty, go to Empress, use the existing 42 inch line through Saskatchewan via Moose Jaw, Regina and Moosomin to Brandon. There, the route takes a right turn, straight south to Steele City, paralleling the first Keystone Pipeline.
That’s roughly 1100 kilometres of new pipe, along an existing right-of-way. And that right-of-way conveniently sidesteps Montana, where a ridiculous Judge Brian Morris twice killed the last project, putting the final nail in its coffin before President Joe Biden backfilled the grave. (Morris is now Chief Judge in Montana’s United District Court, elevated in 2020. Imagine that. Good luck building a pipe through that state.)
We might soon have an incredible alignment, with Donald Trump as president, Republican House and Senate, conservative governments in Edmonton, Regina and quite possibly Ottawa. If Pierre Poilievre displaces Justin Trudeau as prime Minister, we could see an alignment of like-minded governments that might never happen again. But that means we need to make this happen in three years, including approvals, not a decade or longer.
And it can be done. I worked on a crew that, along with several other crews, built a pipeline from Fort St. John, B.C., to Chicago. We got it done, from scratching dirt to in commission, in 16 months from 1999 to 2000. You just need to cut all the ridiculous bovine feces that has crept into the regulatory environment since then, and let fly.
We can do it. We should do it. But we need to move fast.
Brian Zinchuk is editor and owner of Pipeline Online, and occasional contributor to the Frontier Centre for Public Policy. He can be reached at brian.zinchuk@pipelineonline.ca.